Chapter 5: His Sister, Chance Encounter

A single gramophone played through the night, sitting on a desk in a dimly lit room, drowning out the cries of a poor blindfolded prostitute. Her arms were tied behind her to a chair, tears riding down her rosy cheeks. Over the sounds of classical opera, she could hear footsteps nearing her with each step, causing a pit to form in her stomach. Then they stopped, and the blindfold was removed.
Before she could scream, she was shushed immediately by the man in front of her, a white gloved finger placed upon her beautifully chapped lips.
Her blue eyes shimmered with tears, the fear in them causing a wicked smile to form on the man’s mouth. He then pulled out a container of red lipstick and a brush, dipping it in the liquid and to applying it to her bottom lip. Frightened and confused beyond relief, she remained as still as she could so as not to risk her life. But lightning from the storm outside struck, startling her, causing the brush to run off the corner of her lip. The man frowned and roughly grabbed her chin, angered at his ruined handiwork.
Luckily for him, there was a set of sharp metal tools to fix it.
***
“Is this really the time for a game of chess?” Madame Red moved one of her white pawns on the chess board. The rain pitter pattered outside, drumming along lulling tune that complemented the night sky. In the drawing room, Ciel and your aunt were having a cup of tea and playing a game of chess, while you stood at the back dresser, examining the papers of possible suspects with Sebastian.
“Obsessing about it won’t help you solve the case, I wish your sister would understand that. Look at her, fussing about over there and driving herself busy with work. Why not just leave it all to Sebastian, dear?”
“Because he’s simply my chess piece. I’m the one who moves him by giving orders.”
“Well, your dear sister is not a chess piece. You can’t exactly give her orders.”
“No, not exactly.” He smiled. “Although, being the head of the family, I could-“
“Don’t push it, Ciel.” He closed his eye, his smile still remaining. That’s his sister.
“As you can see, Madame Red, her nature is something out of the ordinary, not at all a pawn. If she were in fact a chess piece, she’d be a queen. Able to move in any direction and as far as she needs to in a given move to accomplish her goal; one of the most formidable on the board. On the other hand, Sebastian is no ordinary piece. He can move as many squares as he needs to.” Ciel picked up one of his black knights and used it to knock over Madame Red’s king. “Like that.” She gasped.
“That was against the rules, you know!” Angrily picking up her lost piece and placing it back on the chess board, she huffed at the almost childish move. But what did she expect?
“Indeed.” Ciel interlocked his fingers. “It would be if this was a game, but rules such as that have no true meaning in the real world. There are always knights who break the rules and pawns who betray. If you let your guard down… it’s checkmate.” He then placed his knight upon the chess board, the inanimate eyes of the horse staring straight at her king. For a while it was silent, the room filled with nothing but the shuffling of papers by you and Sebastian and the rain drumming away outside.
“You must’ve had other options in life besides policing England’s underworld. I’m sure my sister, your mother, wanted something else for you two, and yet, after their deaths, you returned to be the queen’s guard dog and his nose. Is it because you’re trying to avenge your parents’ murders?” Even you stopped at that question. Sebastian’s eyes couldn’t help but fall on you, intrigued by your potential response. But you wouldn’t. That was for Ciel discretion, and you couldn’t speak for him. The contract he had with Sebastian was his and his alone, and therefore so was his ultimate objective. Not once was it ever yours, the choices you and he made were independent of the other on that night, and as he so kindly reminded you, he was the head of the family. Whatever he says, goes.
“The need for revenge is a funny thing. It won’t bring the dead back nor will it bring them happiness. But then, to answer your question, we didn’t return to the house of Phantomhive for our parents.” His fingers lightly traced the top of his ring. “We did it for ourselves.” So, he was to speak for you as well then. You resumed shifting through the papers and skimming over their words, much to Sebastian’s bemusement. Be that as it may, while you disagreed with him on certain topics, revenge was not entirely out of the question for you. The difference was merely how much you let it consume you. “I want to find the people responsible for what happened and I want to make them experience the same pain and humiliation that we suffered. I want to make them pay for all the nights I had to endure watching my sister suffer immeasurable pain and not being able to do a damn thing about it.” Your grip on the paper you held tightened, making Sebastian smirk.
Hearing Ciel talk about that time in your life so openly was surprising. It made you a little emotional because you never heard him say that out loud before, although you never really talked about the cult and your time with those people. You never really needed to. Everything you had experienced and how you felt about it was always understood by you both without the need for any real communication, but hearing him actually say those words out loud like that was a little overwhelming. You were honestly a little embarrassed, knowing that Sebastian was watching you intensely the entire time.
Madame Red stared forlornly at your brother with nothing but sympathy, glancing between him and yourself. Even you were affected so drastically by that… time away. She could never imagine what exactly you were subjected to, and truthfully, she didn’t want to know. It would only break her heart more.
“I still remember when you were born…” And the night you were brought to them as well. “Though, it seems so long ago.” She rose from her chair and approached Ciel. “You were both so tiny and fragile, I remember thinking, ‘no matter what, I have to protect them’.” She reached out her hand and patted his head. Her voice was so soft and gentle, so full of sorrow and loneliness… you had never heard her speak in such a way before. “You know I was never able to have children.”
Now that was something that got your attention.
Your head immediately perked up, and your hands stopped shuffling the papers, the emotions that had been welling up inside of you put aside momentarily. Sebastian’s eyes met yours with a smile, but neither of you said a word.
“But then there came you two, and I’ve come to think of you as my own children, which is why I wish you would quit this.” Ciel closed his eye and swatted her hand away.
“This is a task I’ve freely chosen. It’s still my choice to make, and no one else’s. I don’t regret our decision and I won’t be coddled by anyone. I’m sure my sister feels the same way.” Sebastian nearly wanted to add that he was more than happy when his sister embraced him, but he didn’t indulge in such a childish impulse.
A rather human desire.
It appeared that you may be rubbing off on him. He spent so much time around you as it is, but it was a rare treat to see your emotions so blatantly worn on your skin. You were usually able to keep them in check, only subjected to the trivial ones humans experience like frustration, pity, or enthusiasm. The last time he saw you in this state was when you and him first met, stuck in that little cage they put you in, although you were much more open back then. Not that he couldn’t easily decipher your emotions now, but that time was so much different, much more intense. He had to suppress a chuckle. It was a wonder to him what few simple words could elicit from humans. The heart was such a fragile thing.
He could tell Madame Red’s had been broken for some time now, noting her unusual quiet disposition as he was helping to put on her jacket at the front door. Her reaction to what his master said was tasteful, yet predictable; it was nowhere near as entertaining as yours.
“I have it now, thank you.” She didn’t leave though, her red orbs instead meeting his own.
“My lady.”
“Promise me, say you’ll never leave their side. This is a dangerous world for a just boy and a girl… make sure they don’t lose their way?” It was a plead of desperation for her poor niece and nephew, one that he was more than willing to oblige. Sebastian got down on one knee and bowed his head.
“Fear not. I swear I shall stay by their sides until the very end.” Satisfied, Madame Red finally left the mansion, greeted outside by Grell and a carriage, the poor butler having to hold up an umbrella to shield himself from the rain.
“I’m here to escort you back home, my lady.”
***
You had both already gotten changed into your night clothing by the time Madame Red left. Ciel had called you into his room to discuss your findings, so you currently you were sitting on his bed waiting for the demon butler to return. However, you were exhausted, as evident by the large yawn that exited your lips.
“I hope this doesn’t take too long. It’s been quite a long couple of days.”
“Indeed, it has.”
“Did you really have to be so straightforward with auntie?”
“I have no idea what you mean.”
“I’m talking about pushing her away like you did. You know she cares about us, and being shown affection by a family member isn’t a weakness.”
“I meant what I said. I will not be coddled by anyone.” You crossed your arms.
“You don’t seem to mind if it’s from me.” If only you knew Sebastian had thought the very same thing.
“Except I don’t let you coddle me. If we’re going to be more accurate, I usually coddle you. Besides, you’re my sister. It’s different.”
“Not really, and I’ve hugged you a bunch of times before.” He hummed.
“We have been close ever since we were young, especially during those times when all we had was each other. Nothing’s really changed since then.” Before you could respond, the door opened, and in walked Sebastian with the papers you had been looking at earlier. “Well, then?”
“No matter how I look at it, the result is still the same.”
“Yesterday’s murder, the viscount didn’t do it.”
“Exactly. None of the people in his mansion could have done it either.”
“Indeed. No person could move that quickly.” Ciel combed his bangs back. “Anyway, tomorrow we’ll start-” He paused, his now wide eyes suddenly turning to his butler. “Sebastian. You didn’t?” You rolled your eyes.
“Ciel, don’t be an idiot.”
“Of course I didn’t, my lord. I told you, I never lie.”
“He also doesn’t have a reason to murder prostitutes. Plus, it would be going against your orders, so it’s impossible.”
“Thank you for your confidence in me, my lady.” Ciel glared first at you, and then Sebastian, who paid him no mind. “Now, involved in medicine, ties to secret societies or black magic, lacking alibis for the nights the bodies were found… the only human who fits our criteria is the viscount Druit.” His annoyance slowly turned into anger.
“You know more about this than you’re letting on, don’t you?”
“But I’m simply one hell of a butler.” He placed a hand over his heart. “As you well know, I only carry out those orders my master has directly given me.” Before he could lose his temper, you placed a hand on his shoulder to settle him.
“Calm down, Ciel, he technically has a point. Lucky for you though, I’ve already figured it out. I know exactly who Jack the Ripper is.” The papers in Sebastian’s hands were tossed into the air.
“You need only say the words, my lord, and I become either your pawn or your knight. Now, master… move me to check.”
***
It was cold. Bitingly so. Although, being in a dark alleyway in the middle of a rainy night disguised as common city folk, you expected it as such. You almost wish you had Sebastian’s black trench coat that he was wearing, that would at least shield you a little. However, if all three of you dressed in that fashion, you would’ve undoubtedly called attention to yourselves on the way over here. You had to look natural, which is what you were trying to accomplish as you and Ciel casually leaned up against a brick wall outside of a particular person’s house.
“He’ll show if we stake out this place, right?” Your brother asked.
“Definitely, if my prediction is correct.”
“I wish you would just tell me who it is already.”
“Come on, I’m sure someone as smart as you can figure it out. I’m not the only one good at games in this family. Besides, it’s not an answer I like admitting out loud.” He sighed, leaning his head back up against the wall, pondering over what you said. It was a while before he got a twinkle in his eye.
“You know, I’ve realized the murdered prostitutes had other things in common besides their profession.”
“The most beautiful, glossy black hair.” Sebastian mumbled.
“Are you finally catching on?”
“But I still don’t understand why he had to kill them all.”
“Now… that’s a little trickier to answer. I sort of do, yet not really. Not when looking through my eyes, that is. Death is never the answer to our problems in life, even if it was the cause of them.”
“So very loveable, it could almost be a sin.” This caused you to raise a brow at Sebastian, wondering if he was seriously talking about death being loveable. Although when you saw what had him so preoccupied, you abandoned your post on the wall and joined him.
“And what’s more, I-“
“So soft. Ah, so soft.”
“And so tiny and fluffy!” A vein nearly popped out of Ciel’s head as he turned and saw Sebastian holding a black cat, with you poking and patting the thing’s head, both completely ignoring him.
“Listen when I’m talking to you two!” Only Sebastian acknowledged him.
“Oh. I apologize, sir, but she’s so beautiful and soft.” You just continued scratching the cat’s ears, being rewarded with a purr of satisfaction that seemed to melt Sebastian’s nonexistent heart.
“We should name her!”
A scream pierced through the night.
Sebastian immediately let the cat go as your heads whipped in the direction it came from.
“How could somebody have gotten past us?”
“Let’s go, sir.” Thinking there was still time to save her, you all bolted straight for the house. Since you were the first, you slammed the door right open, but as soon as you saw what was inside, you instantly regretted that decision.
A woman’s body lay strewn about in the middle of the floor. Blood splattered every inch of it, from her hands to her face, staining her once beautiful skin and hair and pooling around her mutilated torso. Cold dead blue eyes stared blankly up at nothing, the life that once inhabited them freshly voided. The entire lower half of her was torn up beyond recognition, just a mesh of mangled flesh and ripped apart organs. The stench was putrid, worse than anything you had ever smelled before, but one you knew unfortunately well. It was the familiar stench of cruel death. A tiny droplet of red then splashed onto your face, snapping you out of your surprised trance, though your eyes never left the body. You didn’t even see the one who had caused the blood splatter.
“Back up Ciel.” But it was too late. You could feel him suck in his breath behind you as he saw the same gory sight as you. Sebastian immediately placed his arms over your eyes and pulled you back outside.
“Come away!” He moved far enough away so that you couldn’t smell it anymore, but the damage had already been done. Ciel was breathing loudly in your ear, shaking as he tried to process the revolting display of human carnage. It was too much for him to handle; you could hear him empty the contents of his stomach, feeling Sebastian lowering himself a little to allow him to do so.
You, on the other hand, just stood there, breathing calmly. For some reason, and you didn’t know why, but it didn’t bother you at all. The image of her corpse was engraved into your mind along with every minute detail down to the last drop of blood, all freshly painted before your closed eyes as if you were still looking at it, yet none of it made you sick like Ciel. Of course, it was a little unsettling due to how ripped up the body was, but nowhere near nauseating. There was no pit in your stomach, no dizziness, no terror, nothing. You didn’t feel any different at all, almost as if you had never seen the body in the first place. It was strange, and you weren’t sure if you liked it or not.
You reached up and grabbed onto Sebastian’s arm, giving it a light squeeze to tell him that he could let go. At first, he thought you were latching onto him to cope with what you saw. He had been so focused on Ciel that he didn’t realize until now that you weren’t shaking, hyperventilating, or showing any other signs of human trauma. You were completely unaffected. He couldn’t help but smile. You were handling this much better than his young master was, almost as if you were accustomed to this sort of thing.
Splash.
Someone stepped into one of the puddles of blood inside the house. It was most likely the person who had caused the victim’s blood to land on your face when you first opened the door. There were a couple more splashes, and from what you could tell, the person was slowly approaching you three. Tentatively, Sebastian uncovered your eyes to let you see, but still kept his arm around your collar to hold you back against him.
“You’ve made quite a bit of bloody mess of things in there, Jack the Ripper. Or, rather…” The figure finally stepped into the doorway and out of the shadows, revealing to you the true culprit of the crimes that had been plaguing London and you for the past few days.
“Grell Sutcliffe.” You finished for him. So your prediction had been correct.
Grell’s normally yellow eyes were wide with fear, the parts of his face that weren’t covered in blood were as pale as the moon. He reached out a shaking, blood-soaked hand to you both.
“No, no you’re wrong! I-I heard the scream and rushed to help.” You puckered your lips, crossed your arms, and tapped your foot on the ground.
“Really? So you heard a scream all the way from my aunt’s manor and rushed how many miles to help and just happened to end up getting covered in blood. Did you hear that, Sebastian? It appears that there’s nothing wrong and we have no other choice but to go home.” You chuckled at your own sarcasm. “I mean come on, is that seriously the best you could come up with? I know you only had a minute, but still, you could the least you could do is make it a little more believable. How stupid do you think we actually are? I can’t believe I ever held such high hopes for you.”
“Wait my lady! It’s all true, I swear it!” As soon as Grell stepped towards you, Sebastian tightened his hold and pulled you closer to him.
“It’s rude to lie to a lady, I would’ve thought posing as a butler for so long would have taught you that. You can drop the innocent act, Grell. It’s over.” This time the butler remained silent. Only the sounds of rain pitter pattering around you and the droplets of blood being rinsed off of Grell’s clothes could be heard. “You know, this is actually the first time I’ve met someone like you in the human world. You played the role of helpless butler well. Your act had almost everybody completely fooled.” The murderer looked down at the ground with a solemn expression. A pool of blood below his eye trickled down his cheek to even make it seem like he was crying.
“You… you think so?” Then he swiftly brought his head up, eyes gleaming with a sudden mischief, his mouth upturned into a sickening grin with abnormally sharp teeth. “How… kind.” His tone completely changed into something more sinister. Forgoing his old role as gentle butler, he straightened up with a confidence you had never seen before and removed the bow from his head, untying his long brown hair. “That’s great to hear. After all… I am an actress.” Next were his glasses, folding them up and replacing them with something from his inner suit pocket. A comb. “And quite a good one at that.” As he brushed out his long hair, the color along it bloomed as it passed through the comb’s teeth from a dull brown to a bright red. It was actually very pretty, much like the changing color of a cheshire cat. “Of course, you’re not really ‘Sebastian’, are you?” The pitch of his voice raised, which you assumed was his natural voice, as he put on false lashes and replaced his white gloves with a pair of black ones.
“Sebastian is the name my master gave me, so that is who I am. For now.” He tilted his head down so that he could place a pair of red glasses on that matched his hair, accessorized with beads in the shapes of skulls.
“Ah, you’re playing the faithful dog. Well, you’re handsome enough to get away with it. Anyway, here we are, Sebastian… no.” He flipped some strands of his hair in a flamboyant fashion. “I’ll call you Bassy. Let me introduce myself. The Burnett butler, Grell Sutcliffe. What do you say, let’s get along!” He blew a kiss right at the demon butler, and you could actually feel him shudder. You didn’t really blame him though. “Ah, it’s so nice to talk to you in my true form! I admit, I was surprised when I first met you. I’ve never seen a demon playing a butler!”
“But I could say the same about you. I never thought I’d find one of your kind playing a butler either.” Grell began tapping his finger tauntingly against his face. “You’re supposed to be an intermediary between man and god. A Grim Reaper.” Woah. So that’s what he was. You knew he had to be some sort of supernatural being, your guess being another demon or some sort, but you never expected a reaper of all things. “Why would a divine being like you pretend to be a servant?”
“Why, indeed. For now, let’s just say that it was out of love for a certain woman.” There it was. The final piece of the puzzle. The one that had been eluding you since the start of this conundrum: motive. It even caught Ciel’s attention now, having recovered from the early trauma.
“And that woman would be?”
“It should be quite obvious, brother. After all, who did he pretend to serve?”
“That’s my niece, always so discerning.” A woman dressed in all red stepped out of the house, the color of her clothes nearly blending in with the carnage inside, and joined her place beside Grell. “It’s honestly frightening sometimes seeing the capabilities of a mere child. I can’t say I’m not proud though.” Ciel now removed Sebastian’s arm from over his eyes so that he could see for himself the one truly responsible for this fiasco.
“Auntie.” You greeted Madame Red with disdain in your voice.
“Madame.” Her red eyes stoically gazed at all of you, a look you had never thought possible on her. Until recently.
“Well, I hadn’t counted on this. I didn’t think anyone would be able to see who Grell truly is. The only question I have is when you, (Y/n) dear, figured it out.” To her surprise, you smiled.
“On the carriage ride home. You drew immediate unnecessary attention to the fact that you could very well be our culprit. It was strange, but that alone didn’t confirm anything for me. What did was how you kept telling us that you wanted children, specifically a little girl. I couldn’t help but draw parallels to that and forcefully removing prostitutes’ uteri, since prostitutes I would assume have a negative stance on bearing children. And since Grell was your ‘personal butler’, I naturally thought he was involved. I just didn’t know he was a Grim Reaper, that was all Sebastian.” She hummed.
“I should’ve known to be more careful around you, you’re so observing. But why didn’t you call me out right then and there? Why did you wait and go through all the trouble of dealing with the viscount?”
“Because like I told Lau that day, I didn’t have a motive yet. I only found that out recently, but I still kept my eye on you even then. I’ve been watching and paying attention the whole time.”
“Oh, I knew you were a thorn in our side since the moment we met.” Grell bared his fangs at you in a cheeky smile, but then he put a hand on his heart and sighed dramatically. “You wound me though, knowing that I couldn’t fool a mere human with my superior acting talents. I think I may have lost my touch.” One of his eyes opened, and he couldn’t help but smile again. “I did like you though. Madame Red always talked so fondly about you, going on and on about how you were like her own little girl, and when I finally met you, I can’t say I was disappointed.” He winked, which made you lean back into Sebastian more. Now you know how he felt. Irked at his behavior towards you, Ciel stepped forward in front of you and Sebastian.
“Naturally, you were on the suspect list from the very beginning. But all of your alibis seemed flawless.”
“Even you, Ciel, suspected your own aunt?”
“We were looking for a murderer. Degree of relation to me didn’t matter. None of the humans on the suspect list could have been responsible for all the murders, but if one of them had an inhuman accomplice, that would change the game completely. It had to be someone who could enter and leave a room without being noticed. Someone who could travel from the viscount’s house to the East End instantaneously.”
“In the end, you two were the only ones who could be Jack the Ripper, Madame Red and Grell Sutcliffe. Additionally, when the murders were first announced, I began to look into them on a hunch and discovered a pattern besides prostitution. They’d all undergone a certain surgery. That was the lead that I had found and the reason we were in London, besides the queen’s orders of course.”
“On (Y/n)’s suspicion, I looked into them further and found that they had undergone this surgery at the hospital you work at.” Ciel took out a folded slip of paper from inside his clothes. “We made a list of all the patients. One, the only one who was still alive, was a woman by the name of Mary Kelly.” He unfolded it and showed Madame Red the transcript of the woman who was now dead.
“We knew if we waited around here, you would come for her eventually. But we were… too late.” She saw the looks of sadness on your faces, and she almost felt sorry. Almost.
“My darling niece and nephew, how unfortunate this turned out to be. If you had let it go, we could’ve played chess again, or dressed you up like we talked about, (Y/n). But now…” Her hands clenched together in fists, and you instinctively hovered over your concealed weapons. “You’ve taken everything!”
It all happened so fast. The whirring of a chainsaw, Grell launching at you in a blur of red; you tried to grab your daggers, but you were too slow. You wouldn’t make it in time. Except having a demon butler as your brother’s ally really was quite helpful. Sebastian stepped in front of you and pressed his hands together against the side of the chainsaw, stopping it from advancing, and then pushed Grell back. You still pulled out your daggers, twirling them around in your fingers to a comfortable attacking position, and held them up, ready to defend yourself.
“I’m still too slow. I’m sorry to disappoint you, Sebastian. As your student, this must be embarrassing for you.”
“Nothing a few pointers shouldn’t be able to fix. Besides, that is why I’m here, my lady.” Sebastian held a hand in front of you as Grell landed only a yard away.
“What is that?!” Ciel asked, gesturing to the chainsaw weapon.
“Grim Reapers use tools for harvesting souls.”
“A death scythe.” You whispered breathily in amazement.
“Precisely.” Although, Sebastian didn’t seem too enthused about your eager curiosity of the weapon, and actually, neither was the grim reaper himself.
“Don’t you dare call it that! This is so much more than a scythe! I worked very hard to customize it!”
“Oh, I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to be disrespectful.”
“(Y/n) don’t apologize to him! He’s trying to kill us!”
“What? I don’t want to be rude! I mean Sebastian did call him a divine being, I’ve got to show some respect even if he is trying to kill us.” Ciel facepalmed, and even Sebastian frowned.
“I may have called him a divine being, but this creature warrants no respect from you, my lady. Trust me.” You nearly laughed. It almost sounded like he was jealous of your attention being diverted from him for once, although that was probably a childish fantasy. The Grim Reaper turned rather jovial at your apology, though still apparently slighted by Sebastian’s comment.
“Ugh you wound me so Bassy! But thank you, dearie, I do appreciate the apology.” He then smirked, beginning to show off his rather gorgeous weapon. “This is a special scythe of my own design. It can hack anyone into tiny pieces! And since you’ve been so kind, I can make your death quick and painless! That is, once I deal with your dog.” Grell winked at you then struck a pose, yellow eyes staring coyly into Sebastian’s. “I’ve been far too well behaved. I’m getting out of shape! I would love to exercise my skills. So. Shall. We. Play?” His pose changed with each word, his movements mocking those of a cat. Sebastian’s eyebrow twitched. You had never seen him so annoyed before.
“Perhaps you could be a bit more respectful of my position. I’m on duty, after all.” Grell blushed, putting his hand up to his chin like a squealing school girl, waving his death scythe around like it was nothing dangerous.
“What a stoic man you are! That makes you even more irresistible.” Was he… hitting on Sebastian? You and Ciel looked at each other, both seeming to have the same question in mind: what the hell was going on? “You know, red is my favorite color.” His voice lowered to a serious lilt, and you went back into a defensive position as he in turn took a step forward, bringing the chainsaw into a lunging stance. Sebastian instantly put his arm out in front of you and Ciel, but that didn’t deter the reaper. “It’s perfect for hair, for clothes, for lipstick… so I painted all those women with pretty, pretty red blood. So, Bassy, now I’ll make you even better looking than you are. I’ll tear you up on the inside, and trust me I’ll make you like it.” He winked. “You’ll be as lovely as scattered rose petals. And then I go after your brats, but the polite one goes last. I feel like she’ll have the prettiest shade, and the best must always be saved for last.” You gulped, tightening the grip on your weapons in response. Sebastian however merely turned his back to Grell, much to his chagrin, and began to unbutton his trench coat.
“You’re a Grim Reaper. Your job is to quietly harvest the souls of the dying.” He placed the coat over Ciel’s drenched body, then slightly moved your arms to correct your position, smirking as you frowned and blushed in embarrassment. “And as a butler, your job is to follow your master like a shadow. You have violated both of these expectations, and quite frankly…” Sebastian swiftly turned around with a deathly frown upon his face. “I find it sickening.” Grell displayed his sharp teeth.
“Bassy, you wound me.” The chainsaw began to spin. “You know, I’m more deadly efficient than I seem.” Ciel removed the cotton patch upon his eye, his pentagram seal glowing. He had enough of this foolishness, and he would no longer stand by and allow this creep to taunt them and threaten his sister’s life in front of him.
“In my name and that of the queen, I order you, Sebastian… put an end to them.” Rustic red turned to a feline fuchsia.
“Indeed, my young lord.” Sebastian bit the end of his glove and pulled on it. There was a low chuckle by Grell that you could barely hear over the whirring of the chainsaw.
Then he attacked.
Demon and Grim Reaper collided with massive tenacity. They were like lightening, you could barely keep up with them out of the corner of your eye. Sebastian dodged effortlessly with each swipe of the weapon, backing himself further and further towards the wall of the adjacent building.
“Oooh yes! Please run away, we can play tag, Bassy!” The demon butler’s feet moved with grace even as his moves got more elaborate, eventually being forced to backflip and land a distance away from the reaper. However, he was shocked to feel his opponent already directly behind him. Ready to end his existence.
Luckily, he turned just in time to stop the weapon, putting his hands against the metal sides as he was pushed into the wall behind him, the chains cutting directly through the bricks. But he couldn’t stop it from descending towards his shoulder.
“But see what happens if you’re not fast enough? You get cut!” The black fabric on his shoulder tore, making the reaper chuckle. “It’s more fun when it hurts a little bit though, isn’t it?”
Meanwhile, you had your own problem to deal with. Madame Red was advancing, and you stepped in front of Ciel, bearing your daggers to show that you would be able to put up a fight. But the smile never left her rosy lips.
“You’re still the queen’s guard dog, Ciel, which means that now I’m your prey. Your fangs are bared by your dear sister here, so if it’s hunt or be hunted…” She pulled a knife from within the sleeve of her red cloak. “There’s only one thing I can do!” You met her blade for blade. Then, with only one of them being used, you immediately lunged with your second blade, aiming a blow for her midsection, which she graciously dodged. She then tried to aim for Ciel, but you crossed your daggers together and blocked her, effectively keeping her at bay. You smirked at Ciel behind you.
“And you said training was useless for me.” Madame Red pushed you away but you kept going, strike after strike, parry after parry. Just like in practice. You kept repeating to yourself, just like your practices with Sebastian. He was much faster than her, so this was easy compared to his sessions in terms of speed. Plus, you had two daggers instead of one, which gave you the upper hand. However, you were still at a huge disadvantage due to your height differences, meaning she was able to strike in more angles and keep you at bay better. Additionally, you also had Ciel to worry about instead of just yourself. One wrong step and she would have access to him, and you weren’t sure if Sebastian would be able to aide you if that were to happen, being busy with his own opponent. It was up to you for now.
“I always knew you were a fighter, (Y/n), but I never thought you’d be so cold hearted as to strike your own aunt!”
“And I never thought you’d try to kill your thirteen-year-old niece and nephew, auntie. It seems we all have surprises up our sleeves.” Your (e/c) eyes went wide as she narrowly missed your torso. Dammit. She was aiming for your vital arteries. Being a doctor, she knew exactly where she would need to strike in every possible location, and you only knew some of them. You had to avoid getting closer to her, since a single mistake could very well be your life, but because of your shorter reach, you had to get close to land a blow. There weren’t many options for you but to dodge or risk dying on the spot.
Even from his position, Sebastian could see the dilemma you were facing. He had always come at you with the strength of an average adult human male so you would be able to combat most human opponents, but a serial killing doctor was noticeably different. Later, he would have to teach you every place a human can die from one strike, that way you didn’t have to be on your toes as much in the future and you could defend yourself properly.
“Keep your eyes focused, Bassy, otherwise you’ll wind up staining the wall!” Unfortunately, he couldn’t do anything to help you right now. You were on your own.
It was getting harder and harder to be able to find an opening. Madame Red was surprisingly good, which was unfortunate for you. Your predicament was only made worse when you felt a sharp pain in your side, finding that a scalpel blade had been implanted there.
“I missed.” You hissed as you pulled it out, blood trickling down your chest and staining your white top red. Thankfully it wasn’t in there too deep and it was basically the size of a small scratch, nothing you couldn’t brush off.
“Good move.” You came at her faster, swiping at her as much as you could, all the while keeping an eye on any extra surgical materials she may have hidden. As her arm came at you from the side, you blocked with your fist and aimed a side kick to her midsection, forgetting momentarily about her other hand. It was too late to stop yourself as she pulled out a pair of surgical scissors and swiftly cut your calf clean across while you kicked her. You yelped as she was pushed back, lifting your wounded leg by your side as blood poured from it. Sebastian and Ciel’s eyes went wide, while Grell and Madame Red smirked.
“Unfortunately, you’re not good enough.” You panted, almost completely out of breath as you tried to keep yourself steady. But this wasn’t enough to deter you. Raising your daggers to your eyes, the tips pointed directly at her heart, you challenged her.
“Wanna bet?” Despite your limp, you pushed through the pain and charged. She was surprised that you were able to move at all, barely evading your attack, your dagger tearing at the base of her shirt and slicing into some of her skin. But what did she expect; the pain you endured on the night you were brought home was much more severe than her little infliction. In a way… she was almost proud.
The leg wound had taken its toll, and you ended up losing your footing multiple times, and now that she had two blades on her, you couldn’t get close enough. She even managed to slice open your side, crying out as the blade went deep. But even then, you kept going, pushing through the pain. However, luck was not on your side. Your leg wound combined with the soaked concrete caused you to slip, this time unable to stop Madame Red from aiming for your heart. Ciel immediately reached out and wrapped his arms around you, pulling you towards his chest to prevent you from being killed. But at the cost of saving you, he was deeply cut in the bicep. This alarmed Sebastian, who was still fending off Grell’s chainsaw, as he saw his master pull you and himself against the wall, blood beginning to soak his clothes as well.
“You’re a doctor. How could you do it!?”
“You wouldn’t understand if I told you. You’re just children!” Ire akin to a bull’s, she charged Ciel, aiming for his neck. He pushed you out of his arms so you wouldn’t get hurt as she grabbed his neck. “You… you brat.” She was now talking directly to him. Clenching the knife in her right hand, she brought it up above her head.
“You shouldn’t have been born in the first place!” You were too far away; you wouldn’t be able to stop her. But as she was about to kill him, she paused, her eyes glistening with something you couldn’t decipher.
“Master!” Sebastian was frantic. The next thing you knew, his blood was flying everywhere as he appeared behind Madame Red, eyes glowing, his arm extended.
“Stop, Sebastian! Don’t kill her!” At the command of his master, he stopped just inches from her head. Madame Red barely even noticed though, as she covered her eyes with her hands. You could hear quiet sniveling as she backed up, dropping the knife she had to the ground. Sebastian meanwhile kept his arm out, breathing heavily with a large gash across his right shoulder, which he then proceeded to grab. Seeing him wounded so horribly, Ciel couldn’t help but gasp.
“Your arm…” Grell cackled, his chainsaw buried into the wall where Sebastian was just moments ago, blood covering the weapon and the surrounding bricks.
“How sweet you are, Bassy. Really, what a prince!” With one swift pull, the chainsaw was free. “Sacrificing your own poor limb to save that kid. On the other hand, you’re a disappointment, Madame. Come now, hurry up and kill the brats already. Look, I’ll even help you out by starting with this one!”
Time seemed to freeze. Your back was turned, but you could clearly hear the buzzing of the chainsaw that was now directly behind you, louder than your own rapidly beating heart. Your (e/c) orbs turned to see the whirring metal inches from your face; Ciel, Sebastian, and even Madame Red watched in shock. Out of fear for your life and anger at this armed buffoon, your brother’s sealed eye glowed, and Sebastian moved to obey his orders. But you were quick.
Daggers met chainsaw in a sparking match. Grell was strong though, and you were no match for the moving blades on his weapon. Your hands were pushed away, but each time he came at you, you were able to block it in the nick of time. Sebastian couldn’t even get close without either of you cutting himself, so he waited for his chance to interfere. Grell then struck from an angle that allowed you to turn his arm and push your daggers against the side of the chainsaw. The reaper just smirked and pressed the side of his weapon down against you, the whirring blades nearing your head.
“Damn, and I thought you were out for the count.” Even though you were struggling to hold him back, you managed to quip back at him.
“It’s almost a real shame we have to fight like this. I really liked you Grell, even if it was a farse from the get-go. Even now, I don’t totally hate you, in fact I have to applaud your performance.”
“Thank you. You know, I always did find your presence amusing, and it’s not too often a human recognizes my talent for what it is. But flattery will get you nowhere darling, you still have to die!”
“I know. I just wish you would’ve told me who you really are, I think we would’ve gotten along rather well. After all…” Even though you were in pain, you managed to smile. “My favorite color is red too.” The smile instantly fell right off of Grell’s face, and he stopped pushing his scythe down onto you.
“…What did you say?” Sebastian used this distraction to his advantage, immediately getting in between you and kicking Grell away, who was much too spaced out to defend against him. The reaper landed a few feet away, but his yellow eyes remained on you in what almost look like disbelief. The demon butler stepped in front of you.
“Stay back, my lady.” Grell didn’t move to attack, instead he turned the chainsaw off and held it to his side.
“Say that again.” He then pointed at you. “The last thing that you said.” You tilted your head in confusion.
“…My favorite color is red?” As soon as the words left your mouth, the reaper’s eyes bulged, his jaw went slack, and he nearly dropped his scythe.
“Little (Y/n)… dear heavens, is that really you?”
“Uhhh-”
“Oh my word it is! Little (Y/n)! Darling it’s been ages, I thought I’d never see you again after they took you away! Aw look at you, just as cute as you did all those years ago when we first met all covered in red. Although you’re much more grown up now, and a noble at that! I can’t believe I didn’t recognize you until now, how silly of me. I do hope you forgive me for being so rude and trying to kill you and all, but I wish you would’ve told me sooner! I could never kill a sweet little tart like you!” Sebastian’s eyes met yours in confusion, and you in turn gave him a look that said, ‘I have no idea what the hell he’s talking about’. And you really didn’t. The first time you had ever met Grell was around the time you and Ciel returned to the mansion about two years ago. It certainly wasn’t that long ago, and you don’t think you were that much smaller than you were now. You certainly weren’t covered in blood, you had been well cleaned up before then.
“Sorry, I think you might have me mistaken for someone else. I have no idea what you’re talking about.” He immediately stopped all his gushing and blinked at you. Then he clicked his tongue and shook his head.
“That’s right, how could I forget. They must’ve taken your memories. Those brutes, always ruining everything fun in that daft old place. No matter. You see, we met a long time ago, way before all this Jack the Ripper nonsense. I believe you were only four.” There was a faint ache sprouting in your head, and you placed one of your hands on it. “Starting to remember already? They must not have done a very good job.”
Ciel quickly looked to Sebastian, reminding him of his orders. He didn’t know what the grim reaper was talking about more than you did, but apparently he knew you before your life as a Phantomhive. He didn’t know why or how, and he didn’t really care at the moment. All he knew was that you couldn’t find out of your adoptive status, no matter what. He would not risk you leaving him for anything, even to find out about your past; he was always afraid of that, even before the fire. He was always afraid of you leaving him. Keeping your past a secret was one of the first orders he gave the demon, and one of the most important. Sebastian admittedly was curious. He never knew a human could knowingly make contact with a grim reaper, and the place and the people he was talking about, he couldn’t mean… oh your life just kept getting more interesting by the minute. Pushing his curiosity aside for now, he stood ready to obey his master’s orders.
“But let’s discuss this later.” Grell turned to Madame Red, who hadn’t really been paying attention to this interaction, still covering her watering eyes with her black gloves. “Now, Madame. Kill him.” She slowly lowered her hands.
Through teary eyes, she could see her sister’s face in his own. He resembled Rachel so much, especially the stunning blue of his eye. It brought back so many memories, but none stronger than the love she held for her sister. And as Ciel stared up at her with fear, she was overcome with the memory of when things were well. When Ciel and you were so little, and Rachel and Vincent were still alive, and she couldn’t help but see those precious memories come to life before her.
She saw them. All of them. Her sister, her husband whom she loved, Ciel… he was so much happier back then, especially when (Y/n) came into the picture. They were all much happier back then, including her. Ciel was the last remnant of that happiness and the love she once had. The love she still had.
“I can’t. I can’t kill him. I can’t kill their beloved son.”
“Really? You’re getting soft-hearted on me all of a sudden? After all those deaths? I mean (Y/n) is one thing, she’s a rare human gem. But him? If you don’t end him, he’ll end you.”
“Madame.” You don’t think you’ve ever seen Ciel as sympathetic as now.
“But… this dear boy… this child is my-” She was stopped dead in her tracks. Metal pierced her heart, the chainsaw that protruded from her chest holding her body up in the air. Your jaws dropped as the blood began pouring from her chest and her mouth, before she was discarded by the reaper.
“Too late for that! How disappointing. What use do I have for you if you’re just another woman!?” Her body was suspended in the air, her face frozen in shock and terror. From amongst the red, something else began to pour out of her chest. Lines of black segmented squares emerged from her body, quickly stretching out into the open air above you. Like snakes, they wove around you, Ciel, and Sebastian, and upon closer inspection you saw multiple pictures of what looked like moments in time. It was film, you recognized it from all the papers you read. The one in front of you was a string of pictures of your aunt and… your mother. Sebastian rose from his crouching position, looking directly at the source of the film.
“Is that her-?”
“A part of the reaper’s job is to replay and examine the memories of those who are on the To-Die list. From that we determine what kind of person they were. We see from their own perspective what kind of life they’ve lived, and we decide whether they should live or die.” Sebastian frowned.
“Their lives flash… right before their eyes.”
“Ugh, please, that’s such a pedestrian term!” Grell lifted his scythe in excitement. “It is so much more than that. This is the reaper’s true power: the Cinematic Record.”
You watched it all play out before you. Every moment of your aunt’s life was before your eyes. How she hated the natural color of her hair she had inherited. The time she first met your father, where he called her hair beautiful like spider lilies. And when she realized she had fallen in love with him.
A tear dripped down your cheek, which made Sebastian notice your vacant expression as you watched the film fly by. You were actually reading it. Grell simply smirked.
“I see you still remember the lessons I taught you, darling. The secret to how a human can read a Cinematic Record, the one that only works for you.” You paid no mind to either them, instead concentrating on your aunt’s life as the film continued to tell its tale. This time, Sebastian truly was shocked.
“That’s impossible.”
“Not for this girl. I told you, this one is special.”
Their wedding was beautiful. Your parents’, that is, and she thought so too. Even though she was sad and returned to hating the color red, she never hated them. You smiled as you watched her get married herself, eventually becoming pregnant. Her and her husband were so happy, you had never seen her like this. You never knew she had been expecting… but then you saw why. The smile disappeared off your face as you watched the carriage accident unfold, then the doctor informing her of her husband’s death as well as how they were forced to remove her uterus along her unborn child.
Right after she left the hospital, she found your home in flames, covered with the color she hated. You nearly vomited as that moment was relived right before your eyes. Then there was the funeral for your parents… that was one thing that had always bothered you. Neither you nor Ciel got to say goodbye. Seeing the funeral, even though it was from a different perception, almost made up for that.
Her happiness had been taken away, and then one day at work came a prostitute, one who you recognized as one of the murder victims, asking her to remove her unborn child. The rage behind those red eyes was immeasurable, and you understood why. Madame Red would’ve given everything to have what this woman had, but she saw it as a nuisance. She would snuff out a life that hadn’t even had the chance to live so that she could continue her occupation. You still didn’t think the woman should’ve died as gruesomely as she did for that, but still, you felt sorrow for your aunt. Even as you watched the first murder play out in horrific detail, you felt only sadness and grief.
That was when Grell appeared. Not long after, she had heard of your return, and some of the happiness that she had lost returned. You actually remembered that day when she came to see you. She brought you both into a big hug, though now you could see that when she looked into Ciel’s face, she recognized a trace of her sister.
You thought back to the conversation you had with her when she was dolling you up for the party. How she said she would want do the same for your marriage, and how she wished she had her own little girl. It never crossed your mind that she truly considered you her own. Especially after you told her one day about your favorite color, which was replaying before you right now. You told her that it was because of her that you liked red so much; you had always admired her hair and how unique it was. You never understood why she had pulled you into such a tight hug after you said that… but now you do.
However, her happiness slowly turned to anger as more of the memories passed, doubt and jealousy consuming her as she continued to murder and take what had also been taken from her. She wished so desperately that her life had been different, that for a moment, she was willing to kill you two to deal her own justice.
The pain in your head intensified as the film disappeared, the blood still flowed from Madame Red as her body finally dropped to the ground. Grell stared at her corpse with nothing but emotionless disdain.
“How beautiful you were dyed in crimson, covered in your victim’s blood. I loved you so.” He tossed away his black overcoat and began to approach her. “What a disappointment you turned out to be in the end. You don’t have what it takes to wear red.” He removed the red coat on your aunt’s body and put it on himself. “Your cheap little melodrama ends now.” He then picked up his scythe and turned his back to her. “It’s over, Madame Red. Goodbye.”
While you were clutching at your head, Ciel grabbed your hand in his and gave it a squeeze, rubbing his thumb gently over your palm to try and distract you from the pain. Also, as a way to comfort you. Your aunt just died, and you just watched every moment of her life play out before you. He heard Sebastian and Grell talking about the Cinematic Record, and judging by the way they reacted to you, humans were not supposed to be able to read it; he would have to discuss this with Sebastian later. But right now, you were still crying for Madame Red. Whatever you saw must’ve been heartbreaking.
With his other hand, he gently shut his dead aunt’s eyes out of respect. She could finally be at peace, and you seemed to be happy with that.
“That just leaves you, little (Y/n), darling.” You looked up to see Grell staring at you. “I have to say, I really was surprised to see you here among these people, and I was especially excited to know that you can still read Cinematic Records. I’m glad to see my lessons stuck. Have you remembered anything from that night then?” You doubled down as the pain in your head intensified, the small ache transforming into an agonizing throb that seemed to ram against your skull; it was as if something was trying to break free. “I can tell you everything, you know. I’ll never forget the first time I saw you stained with blood. You told me then that your favorite color was red too.” He stepped closer. “You should join me. Leave Bassy and his kid alone to play by themselves. There’s a lot more I can teach you, oh, and we could go shopping for all new clothes together! We can pick out a pair of glasses to replace your old ones.” Ciel glared at him, though he either didn’t notice or didn’t care. “Come now, aren’t you at least a little curious as to why you can read a Cinematic Record?” Your brother tightened his hold on you. Even if you wanted to, he wouldn’t let you go.
“Well, what are you waiting for?” Sebastian instantly looked down at his master. “I thought I ordered you to put an end to Jack the Ripper. It’s not over yet.” Ciel turned around to face Sebastian, still keeping his arms on you to steady yourself. “One is left. Stop standing there and kill him!” The surprise melded off the butler’s face, and in its wake was a determined smirk.
“Certainly.” Grell scoffed.
“I was going to spare you if you had just given her to me. Professional courtesy and all that, but if you insist…” Grell turned on his chainsaw and brought it up over his head. “I’ll send you and the boy straight to heaven together!” He swiped at where Sebastian was aiming, but he missed, the demon butler bending his body and stopping mid-attack to avoid the scythe.
“Heaven? You’re joking.” Grell gasped as he felt a weight on the tip of his blade, Sebastian standing as stiff as a board on top of it like it was nothing. “I know nothing of heaven.” As soon as Grell turned around, he was met with a side kick which he fortunately ducked just in time. As Sebastian landed just a few feet away, Grell blushed and accusingly pointed his chainsaw at him.
“You would kick a lady in the face!? Where are your manners, sir!”
“Terribly sorry, you see I’m one hell of a butler.”
“Ha! You think a demon like you can beat a reaper?”
“Certainly. You see if my master tells me to win, then I shall win.” Grell placed a hand on his hip and huffed.
“You care a lot about that puny little brat, don’t you? I’m jealous. Demon or not, you’ll still be destroyed if I reap you with my death scythe. Aren’t you frightened?” Sebastian merely placed a bloodied glove over his heart.
“Not at all. I belong to my master. My soul and my body, down to the last hair, are his. The contract remains, so I follow his every order. That’s what it means to be a butler.”
“But you’re not hers. You’re only obligated to follow his orders, so why do you care about her?”
“Be that as it may, as the younger sister of my master, I have been given orders to defend her with my life.” He tightened his gloves, prepared for the fight to come. Whatever may have happened to you in the past with the reaper was irrelevant, all that mattered now was his master’s orders. All by a chance encounter on a rainy night like this one so many years ago, he now had a duty to protect you at all costs, and he would uphold that duty until the day his master’s soul became his. Especially now that your life was just starting to get interesting. “And that is exactly what I shall do.”
(A/N: Here’s that second chapter I promised! Hope it’s not terrible, haha. Story’s finally getting juicy though, hope you liked the sneak peek into the reader’s past 😉 . I don’t know when I’ll be able to get to this again, but thanks to everyone who’s been sticking it out this long with me. Life gets really busy sometimes, so it’s hard to find time sometimes to write, but I try to manage. Anyway, hope you guys enjoy the holidays and I’ll see y’all laters ~_~)



“Bloody hell! This wire’s done for!” Baldroy yelled, lying upside down on the floor while holding a chewed up wire. Finny and Mey-Rin were by his side.
Soft snores filled the otherwise quiet, dark room, as you peacefully lay tucked under your covers, sound asleep. The door creaked open slowly, careful so as not to disturb your slumber. Red eyes peeked in, surveying the room, and once they caught sight of the still sleeping girl, the male they belonged to entered the room. The door was shut just as quietly as it was opened, and the male walked over to your sleeping form. He placed a hand on your shoulder and lightly shook it.



